25 Sweet and Thoughtful Baptism Gifts

by mkimmel | Last Updated: May 31, 2021

If you are in the market for the best baptism gifts, you came to the right place! Here are 25 of the sweetest and most thoughtful baptism gifts you can get for the newly christened angel in your life. From adorable plush toys to comfortable onesies, you’ll find what you’re looking for here. Check it out, now!

Mud Pie Blessings Jar

Mud Pie Blessings Jar

Crafted with a dolomite material, this elegant blessings jar from the Mud Pie store makes one of the simplest yet most thoughtful baptism gifts. This jar looks rustic and elegant at the same time featuring a classic design and a super clean finish. This one is perfect as a keepsake container or a baptismal message jar. Also, this blessings jar features minimalistic text on the front side.

Simple Joys Sleeper Gowns

Baptism Gifts: Simple Joys Sleeper Gowns

These sleeper gowns from Simple Joys make awesome baptism gifts for a baby. Made from 100% cotton, these gowns come in a handful of designs and patterns. A set of these includes 3 gowns that feature a pull-on closure and are machine-washable. Plus, the sleeves on these gowns are cinched making them warm and comfortable to wear.

Noah’s Ark Play Set

Baptism Gifts: Noah’s Ark Play Set

This Noah’s Ark playset from Hallmark is another fantastic choice for a baptism gift. It’s fun, colorful, and makes a perfect introduction to biblical stories. The set includes a carrying basket that resembles Noah’s ark as well as 4 mini plush toys. This is definitely something the newly christened baby will love!

My First Rosary Cross

Grasslands Roads’ My First Rosary cross set comes with a ceramic jar container. It has beautifully crafted beads that make an awesome keepsake and a useful rosary. With two colors, white and pink, this rosary cross set is something simple yet elegant. It ships inside a protective gift box ready for gifting.

Plush Swaddle Blankets

Plush Swaddle Blankets

With 5 awesome colors to choose from, these plush swaddle blankets are great gift ideas. These blankets are designed especially for babies’ tender skin. It features a super warm and super soft texture, plus, it is extremely easy to wash as well. If you are looking for useful baptism gifts, this one is something to consider.

Baptism Picture Frame

Baptism Picture Frame

For a truly simple baptism gift, this picture frame would make a fantastic choice. This hinged photo frame measures 4×6 inches and comes with a lovely poem. This frame can be displayed on countertops and other flat surfaces. It features a simple brushed metal finish as well as glass front and back photo covers.

Willow Tree Guardian Angel

Willow Tree Guardian Angel

If you are looking to gift a keepsake item, this figurine from the Willow Tree store is something to consider. With a written sentiment that reads “May you always have an Angel to watch over you,” this would make a heartfelt gift. This hand-painted 5-inch figure features an angel holding a toddler. This is surely one of the most awesome baptism gifts out there.

Noah’s Ark Coin Bank

Noah's Ark Coin Bank

This Noah’s Ark coin bank is another awesome baptism gift item. It comes in a gift-ready box and it has a tarnish-free finish. This coin bank measures 4 inches in height and 5 inches in width, and it would make a practical tool in teaching kids how to save money. Also, this coin bank has engraved drawings of Noah’s ark alongside a few friendly-looking animals.

Complete Baptism Gift Set

Baptism Gifts: Complete Baptism Gift Set

If you simply want to give a bit of everything as your baptism gift, this set of complete baptism gifts is something to look at! It comes with a cute plush toy, baby’s first bible, a cross, a prayer book, and a greeting card. This suits the occasion quite perfectly, plus, it comes in two colors, blue and pink as well. You will not go wrong with this gift set, for sure!

Baby’s First Bible

Baby's First Bible

Baby’s First Bible is a book set of 4 different biblical stories. These storybooks are filled with colorful and bright illustrations as well as child-friendly language. Included in the set are The Story of Moses, The Story of Jesus, Adam and Eve, and Noah’s Ark. This book set is amongst the most suitable baptism gifts you can get.

Baptism Dedication Gift

Baptism Dedication Gift

For the special newly christened baby in your life, this baptism dedication gift might be the best gift to get. Complete with tons of colorful pictures, this book cherishes everyday blessings through gratitude. This dedication gift book contains 20 high-quality pages with an 8.5×8.5-inch size. Also, you can personalize this book by writing the child’s name on the dedication page!

Precious Moments Ceramic Jar

Precious Moments Ceramic Jar

This simple ceramic jar from Precious Moments has an adorable miniature elephant figure on top. It has a round-shaped base and a smooth finish. This jar is approximately 7 inches tall and it would make an awesome keepsake container. The jar also features an embossed tag with a painted message which reads “bless this baby.”

Jesus Loves Me Snow Globe

Jesus Loves Me Snow Globe

Speaking of keepsake, this snow globe is another fantastic gift idea. It comes in two variants, boy and girl, and it is made with tough polycarbonate plastic. This snow globe is made from a hand-crafted cold-cast resin and it would make a wonderful decoration in the baby’s room. Also, the globe plays the lovely tune of Jesus Loves Me.

UAU Baby Lounger

Baptism Gifts: UAU Baby Lounger

If you are looking for the best practical baptism gifts, this baby lounger from UAU is something to take a closer look at. Made from 100% hypoallergenic cotton, this lounger is super soft to the touch and is suitable for sensitive skin types. It comes in 4 different designs: elephant, blue tree, crown, and rockets. This lounger is machine-washable and easy to carry around.

Jefferies Hand Crochet Booties

Jefferies Hand Crochet Booties

These hand-crocheted booties from the Jefferies Socks store come in white, blue, and pink. Made with 100% cotton, these socks are comfortable and easy to hand-wash. This would fit toddlers from 1 year old to 4 years old. These booties will surely make an awesome baptism gift!

Cotton Hooded Towel Wrap

Cotton Hooded Towel Wrap

If you are gifting a baby who simply hates bath time, these cotton hooded towel wraps might change that. With 3 adorable designs, a gray elephant, a pink princess, and a yellow ducky, this towel wrap is fun and colorful. Also, they look absolutely cute when worn! This would probably be high on the list of the most adorable baptism gifts.

Wind-Up Musical Lamb

This wind-up musical lamb from Mary Meyer is a 12-inch long plushie that sings Jesus Loves me. It is made with a super-soft microfiber fabric which is extremely gentle to the skin. This musical lamb is easy to wash and it makes the perfect baptism gift! This one definitely fits the Christian-themed occasion quite nicely.

Baby Diaper Caddy Organizer

Baby Diaper Caddy Organizer

Here’s a super practical baptism gift for the newly christened baby. This baby diaper caddy organizer from the Lil-Dandelion store comes in 5 different colors: blue, grey, leather, pink, and yellow. It features a felt material on the exterior as well as on the interior. This caddy will fit any size of diapers, extra clothes, and other baby supplies.

Baptism Keepsake Box

Baptism Gifts: Baptism Keepsake Box

If you are already eyeing a baptism gift to get for the newly christened baby in your life, this keepsake box is something to consider. This customizable box has a beautiful finish and an elegant printed label. The written message as well as the name can be personalized to whatever you want. This box is awesome to put photographs, handwritten messages, and other small items in.

Baby Soother

Baby Soother

For that Christian baby in your life who is just not a heavy sleeper, this is the gift to get. The Baby Soother is a nifty little gadget that comes in the form of a cuddly owl. This portable speaker plays lullabies and shushing sounds which help calm babies to sleep. With mesmerizing rotating lights, this will surely make an effective and practical baptism gift.

Bronze Sacrament Keepsake Box

This polyresin keepsake box features a textured outer design and a heartfelt scripture that reads “For I know the plans I have for you.” This keepsake box is handcrafted using a combination of resin and stone. It ships inside a gift-ready packaging and it has a removable lid that secures other keepsake items on the inside. This functional box can store baby’s accessories such as a rosary, a small prayer book, and more!

Cotton Muslin Swaddle

Cotton Muslin Swaddle

Made with 100% cotton, this super-soft baby swaddles blanket from the Ocean Drop Designs store is a sweet baptism gift. It measures 47×47 inches and it has a heartwarming printed message. This shirt comes in a handful of designs and color options, plus, it is easy to care for as well. This is something the newly christened baby in your life will surely find useful.

Baby Handprint Kit

Baptism Gifts: Baby Handprint Kit

This baby handprint kit from the Little Hippo store is amongst the most unique baptism gifts you can get. It is super fun and personalized gift which comes with a unique experience. The kit includes colorful inserts such as pre-cut letters. Also, there are 4 different frame colors to choose from: white, black, rustic white, and espresso.

Praying Bear Plush

Praying Bear Plush

If you are looking for one of the most adorable baptism gifts you can get, this praying bear plush is an awesome gift choice. At 8 inches tall, this bear features white fur and a cute sleeping cap. There is also an in-built voice recording that plays the prayer “Now I Lay Me Down to Sleep.” This one is a fantastic gift that comes in extra handy when teaching kids how to pray.

God Gave Us You

Baptism Gifts: God Gave Us You

This bedtime storybook is about a mama bear and her young cub. It is a hardcover book that features vibrant artworks that are appealing to look at. It has a fun and friendly storyline that toddlers will surely love. This book makes an amazing baptism gift especially because it talks about the wonderful gift of God.